A crew leader called me from a driveway in the wrong subdivision last spring. Right street name, wrong town — one of those county road numbers that repeats three times in forty miles. Two guys, a loaded trailer, 50 minutes of fuel and labour, and a homeowner on the other side of the county wondering where everybody was.
That's the kind of loss you notice. It's annoying, it's visible, somebody gets a talking-to.
Here's the one nobody notices. Same week, the owner measured a 2,400 sq ft re-side on a Thursday afternoon. Wrote the numbers in a spiral notebook, left the notebook in the truck, truck went out on a repair call, notebook got rained on through the open window. Rather than drive back out, he rebuilt the measurements from memory on Monday. Quote went out the following Wednesday — nine days after the appointment. Homeowner had already signed with somebody else on day four.
No one logged that. It didn't show up anywhere. It just quietly didn't happen.
Everybody in this trade is being told to diversify lead sources — Google Ads for intent, social for awareness, a referral program for trust. That advice is fine. It's also useless if the pipe you're pouring those leads into has six holes in it. Buying more leads to cover a leaky process is the most expensive habit in exterior contracting.
So let's price the holes.
The baseline we're working from
Pick your own numbers, but here's the company I'll use so the maths is visible:
- 300 inbound leads a year
- 200 turn into a measure appointment
- 170 get a quote
- 84 close — about 49% of everything quoted
- Average contract: $16,500
- Gross margin: 35%, so roughly $5,775 gross profit per job
- Annual revenue: ~$1.39M
Substitute your averages and the shape of the answer won't change much.
Leak 1: The first ring goes to voicemail
You're on a ladder. You're mid-measure with another homeowner. It's 6:40pm. The phone rings, you let it go, you mean to call back.
Across a year, roughly one in five first contacts doesn't get a live human. Call it 66 of your 300. About half of those will call you back or leave a message you actually return. The other half — 33 people — call the next name on the list and you never know they existed.
The math
33 lost first contacts × 28% overall close rate = 9 jobs. $148,500 in revenue. About $52,000 in gross profit.
The plug
You don't need a call centre. You need every inbound — call, form fill, Facebook message, the text your cousin forwarded — landing in one place with a name attached to it within the hour. A shared lead inbox where anyone in the office can see what came in and who's touched it beats a voicemail box nobody owns. If leads are arriving in four different apps on your personal phone, you've already lost this one.
Leak 2: The nine-day quote
The measure went great. The homeowner liked you. Then the quote sat on your kitchen table for a week while you chased a soffit job across town.
Quote speed is the single most controllable variable in this business and almost nobody controls it. The difference between a quote delivered in 24 hours and one delivered in six days isn't a few points of close rate — it's the difference between being the contractor they're comparing others against and being the third number in an email folder.
The math
Say you quote 170 jobs at a 49% close rate. Getting the average quote turnaround from six days to one lifts that to 55% — conservative, honestly.
170 × 6 points = 10 jobs. $165,000 in revenue. $58,000 in gross profit.
The plug
The reason quotes are slow is almost never laziness. It's that building one means re-deriving your labour rate, digging out what you charged for J-channel in March, and typing the same scope paragraph for the ninth time. Save your pricing once — per square, per lineal foot of trim, per opening wrapped, soffit, fascia, tear-off, disposal — and build quotes by assembling parts instead of starting from blank. This is specifically what ExteriorPro's estimate templates exist for: you measure, you pick line items, the proposal is out before you leave the driveway.
Leak 3: You followed up once
You sent the quote. You called four days later and left a message. Then you decided they'd gone cold, and emotionally, you moved on.
Of 170 quotes, 84 close. That leaves 86 proposals sitting in limbo — not rejected, just unanswered. A re-side is a $16,500 decision with a spouse attached to it. People take weeks. They go quiet because they're getting a second quote, waiting on a HELOC, or arguing about colour.
The math
A structured sequence — day 2, day 7, day 14, day 30 — converts maybe 8% of the pile that would otherwise die.
86 × 8% = 7 jobs. $115,500 in revenue. $40,000 in gross profit.
The plug
Follow-up isn't a personality trait, it's a calendar entry. Every open quote needs a next action with a date on it, and the date needs to be somewhere other than your head. When a quote goes out, the follow-up tasks should be created at the same time, automatically, so skipping them requires a decision instead of just happening.
Leak 4: Nobody knew where the crew was supposed to be
Back to the driveway in the wrong subdivision. This is the leak you can see, which is why it feels like the biggest one. It isn't — but it isn't small either.
Two blown appointments a month is 24 a year. Wrong address, double-booked measure, the homeowner was told Tuesday and you wrote Thursday. Half get rebooked with an apology. Half quietly become somebody else's job.
The math
12 lost opportunities × 49% close-on-quote = 6 jobs. $99,000 in revenue, $35,000 in gross profit. Add the direct cost of 12 wasted crew half-days at loaded labour — call it $540 a pop, $6,500 straight off the bottom line.
The plug
The job address, gate code, dog situation, and homeowner's mobile number need to be on the installer's phone, not on a whiteboard in an office nobody visits at 6am. One schedule, one source of truth, visible to the people driving the truck.
Leak 5: The estimate that quietly underbid itself
This one doesn't lose you leads. It loses you money on the jobs you win, which is worse, because you did all the work.
You priced from memory. You forgot the dumpster. You didn't allow for rot behind the north elevation you couldn't see. You wrapped eleven windows and quoted nine. The crew did the extra work, nobody wrote a change order, and the customer paid the original number.
The math
If one job in four comes in 6% light on contract value: 21 jobs × $990 = $20,800 of margin gone. Add unbilled change orders — $800 average on 30 jobs — and you're at $44,800 of pure gross profit, evaporated.
The plug
A standing checklist on every estimate: disposal, permit, rot allowance, trim wrap count, soffit linear footage, access difficulty. And a change order process that takes two minutes on a phone, because a change order that takes twenty minutes of paperwork will never get written.
Leak 6: The "not this year" pile
"Call us in the spring." "After the kid's wedding." "We're getting the roof done first."
You say sure, you write it on something, and spring arrives with no list.
Sixty of your 300 annual leads are deferrals, not rejections. These are the warmest leads you will ever have — they've already decided they need siding, they've already met you, they've already seen your number.
The math
Reach them at the right time next season and 15% convert.
60 × 15% = 9 jobs. $148,500 in revenue. $52,000 in gross profit.
The plug
A deferred lead gets a future date, not a shrug. Six months out, nine months out, whatever they told you. Then the system surfaces them when the time comes — ideally alongside your past customers, who are the other group you've never systematically called.
Adding it up honestly
Total exposure across all six: roughly $680,000 in revenue and $280,000 in gross profit.
You will not recover that. Nobody does. Half those leads were never real, some of the deferrals move away, and chasing every one of them perfectly would take a full-time employee you don't have.
But capture a third — a realistic, unglamorous third — and that's 10 to 15 additional jobs and somewhere near $90,000 in gross profit, on the same ad spend, with the same crew, in the same market.
Compare that to what another lead source costs you.
Start by measuring, not fixing
Before you change anything, track four timestamps for 60 days: lead received, first contact made, quote sent, decision received. Then look at where the gaps are. Most companies find one leak doing 60% of the damage, and it's rarely the one they assumed.
Fix that one. Then come back for the next.
Ready to get organised?
ExteriorPro is built specifically for exterior contractors — siding, soffit, fascia, gutters — with lead tracking, estimate templates, scheduling, and follow-up reminders in one place, so the leaks above stop being invisible.
Start your free 30-day trial No credit card required. Cancel anytime.