Where Roofing Leads Die: A Dollar-by-Dollar Audit of the 7 Gaps Between the First Call and a Signed Contract

•

Thursday afternoon, your best estimator climbs down off a 28-square tear-off in a cul-de-sac, writes the pitch and the facet count on the back of a shingle wrapper, tells the homeowner "I'll have numbers to you tomorrow," and drives to the next appointment. Friday is three inspections and a supplement fight with an adjuster. Monday the wrapper is under the passenger seat. Wednesday he rebuilds the measurement from memory, sends a PDF with a number he's 90% sure about, and gets a polite reply: We went with someone else — they got us a quote Friday.

That job was worth about $4,300 in gross profit. It didn't die because your crews are bad or your prices are high. It died in the eight days between the ladder and the email.

Most roofing owners think their problem is lead volume. For a lot of shops it isn't. It's that a quarter to a third of the leads you already paid for leak out through seven specific gaps between the first ring of the phone and a signature. This post puts a dollar figure on each one so you can find out which gap is actually costing you the most — and stop guessing.

Set your baseline first

The numbers below are modelled on a residential re-roof company doing about $1.7M a year. Swap in your own figures as you read; the method matters more than my assumptions.

  • 480 leads a year (40/month, mix of calls, form fills, referrals)
  • 300 inspections run
  • 120 jobs sold — a 25% lead-to-sale rate
  • $14,500 average job, 30% gross margin = $4,350 gross profit per job
  • Loaded cost of an estimator's hour: $85, including vehicle

One job won or lost moves $4,350. Hold that number in your head — it's the multiplier for everything that follows.

The seven gaps

Gap 1: The call nobody answers

You're on a roof, your office manager is on the other line, and the phone rolls to voicemail. Homeowners calling about a leak don't leave voicemails. They call the next ad.

Most contractor shops miss 20–30% of inbound calls, and the number spikes exactly when you're busiest — the week after a storm, when every one of those calls is worth more than usual.

Say you miss 25% of 480 — 120 calls. Call back fast enough and you'll recover maybe 70 of them. The other 50 are gone to whoever picked up. At your 25% close rate that's 12.5 jobs, or about $54,000 in gross profit a year.

How to check: pull your call log from your carrier or tracking number and count missed and abandoned calls for the last 90 days. Then check how many of those numbers appear anywhere in your job records. The gap between the two is the leak.

Gap 2: The form fill you answer tomorrow

A web lead at 7pm Tuesday, answered at 9am Thursday, is a different lead. By then they've filled in two more forms and talked to someone. Homeowners typically gather three quotes, and the first contractor to respond gets to frame what "normal" looks like — scope, warranty, price range. Everyone after that is arguing against an anchor somebody else set.

Of 480 leads, say 120 come in as form fills or marketplace leads. The close-rate difference between responding in minutes and responding the next day is real but not magic; call it 10 points. Strip out the ones who also phoned you (no double-counting) and you're left with roughly 6 jobs, or $26,000 in gross profit.

How to check: for your last 50 web leads, log the timestamp of the enquiry and the timestamp of your first successful contact — not your first attempt. If the median gap is over an hour, this is a live gap for you.

Gap 3: The appointment you should never have driven to

Renters. Out-of-area. "Just want a ballpark for my insurance." Someone who wants a repair you don't do. None of these are the homeowner's fault — nobody screened the lead before it hit the calendar.

If 20% of your 300 inspections are unqualified, that's 60 wasted appointments. At 2.5 hours each including drive time and write-up, at $85/hr, that's $12,750 of estimator time burned. The harder cost is what those 150 hours could have been: another 60 real inspections, or 15 sold jobs.

How to check: ask your estimators to tag every appointment as qualified or not for two weeks. Owners are consistently shocked by this one.

Gap 4: The no-show

The appointment set nine days ago, never confirmed. Nobody home. 12% no-show on 300 appointments is 36 trips: 1.5 hours plus 40 miles each, roughly $155 a pop, $5,580 of pure burn.

Worse, about half of those leads never reschedule. 18 leads × 25% = 4.5 jobs, another $19,500 in gross profit. A confirmation text 24 hours ahead and a "driver is 20 minutes out" text kills most of this gap outright. It's the cheapest fix on the list.

Gap 5: The measurement that lives in a truck

Shingle wrappers. Phone notes. A photo roll with 60 pictures from four different houses and no labels. The measurement gets rebuilt from memory, or a second trip gets made, or a number gets guessed.

Say 15% of sold jobs have a measurement or scope discrepancy — 18 jobs. Half need a return visit: 9 × $150 = $1,350. The other half get priced wrong, and underbids run maybe 8% of job value: 9 × $14,500 × 8% = $10,440 of margin gone, before you count the change-order conversations that make customers trust you less.

Call it $12,000 a year, and a chunk of your reputation.

This is the gap where software earns its keep rather than just looking tidy. If measurements, photos and scope notes are captured on the phone at the house and attached to the job record before the estimator drives away, the memory problem disappears. That's a core part of what ExteriorPro does — field data lands in the job file, not in a glovebox.

Gap 6: The proposal that goes out late, or not at all

This is almost always the biggest gap, and almost always the most invisible, because nobody tracks proposals that were never written. There's no record of a thing that doesn't exist.

Of 300 inspections, assume 70% get a written proposal at all. That's 90 inspections with nothing sent. Half of those were genuinely dead on site — storm chaser already signed, homeowner selling, whatever. The other 45 are real opportunities you inspected, paid for, and dropped: 11 jobs, $48,000 in gross profit.

Then the late ones. Of the 210 proposals you do send, say 80 go out after day three. Against competitors delivering a clean digital quote within 24 hours, those lose maybe 12 points of close rate: another 9.6 jobs, $42,000.

Combined: roughly $90,000 a year in gross profit sitting between the inspection and the email.

Two things fix most of it. First, a visible list of inspections completed but proposals not sent, reviewed daily — if it isn't on a list, it doesn't exist. Second, templated pricing so building a proposal takes 15 minutes, not 90. Generating a proposal from the measurements and photos already attached to the job, and seeing which ones are still unsent, is the single highest-value thing most shops get from job-management software. It's the reason ExteriorPro puts the unsent-proposal list on the dashboard instead of three clicks deep.

Gap 7: The follow-up that stopped after one try

You sent the proposal. They said they'd talk to their spouse. You emailed once eight days later. Then you got busy.

Roof decisions take time — financing, insurance timelines, a partner who travels. A structured five-touch sequence over 30 days recovers somewhere around 7% of quotes that have gone quiet. On 120 unclosed proposals a year, that's 8 jobs, $35,000 in gross profit, from work you've already done and already paid for.

How to check: count proposals sent in the last 90 days with zero recorded contact after day 10. For most shops it's the majority.

Rank them against your own numbers

| Gap | Annual gross profit lost | |---|---| | 6. Proposals late or never sent | $90,000 | | 1. Missed calls | $54,000 | | 7. Follow-up stopping at one touch | $35,000 | | 2. Slow response to web leads | $26,000 | | 4. No-shows | $25,000 | | 3. Unqualified appointments | $13,000 | | 5. Measurement rework and underbids | $12,000 |

That totals about $255,000 of gross profit on a $1.7M business. Be honest about what that means: you will never recover all of it. Some of those homeowners were never going to buy from anyone, and some gaps overlap. Recover half and you've added roughly $125,000 to the bottom line without spending another dollar on leads — which, for most shops, is more than the entire marketing budget.

What to do in the next two weeks

Don't fix seven things. Measure seven things, fix one.

  1. Days 1–10: pull your carrier's missed-call report, timestamp your last 50 web leads, and have estimators tag appointments as qualified or not.
  2. Day 10: list every inspection run in the last 60 days and mark which ones have a proposal sent, and on what date. This takes an afternoon and it's the most useful afternoon you'll spend this quarter.
  3. Day 12: multiply each gap by your own gross profit per job and rank them.
  4. Day 14: pick the top one. Give it an owner, a daily check, and a number you review every Friday.

If your biggest gap is missed calls, that's a staffing and routing decision, not a software decision. If it's unsent proposals, slow follow-up, or measurements getting lost between the ladder and the office, that's a process-and-system decision — and those three usually add up to more than everything else combined.

The uncomfortable part of this audit is that none of these gaps show up in your P&L. There's no line item called "quotes I never sent." It just looks like a close rate you can't explain and a marketing spend that isn't working as well as it used to.

Ready to get organised?

ExteriorPro is built for exterior contractors — roofing, siding, gutters — to keep measurements, photos, proposals and follow-ups in one place so leads stop leaking out between the ladder and the signature.

Start your free 30-day trial No credit card required. Cancel anytime.

Ready to Streamline Your Business?

ExteriorPro helps exterior contractors manage projects, create estimates, and grow their business. Start your free 30-day trial - no credit card required.

Get Started Free